Sunday, April 06, 2008

What country club?

As has been widely discussed on many Michigan blogs, Sports Illustrated's Stewart Mandel recently did a piece for SI.com on the Michigan football program during which Coach Rod granted Mandel "exclusive access." In gratitude for the exclusive access, Mandel is highly complimentary of the direction that Coach Rodriguez is taking the program. However, in the article, Mandel is critical of the previous coaching regime. Mandel writes, " All of which makes you wonder: If this new approach is really as shocking as Boren, Schilling and others have expressed, what kind of country club was Carr running all those years? And is that why Michigan, for all its considerable talent, has largely underachieved in the decade since its 1997 national championship, including six losses in seven years against Ohio State?" (emphasis added)

Mandel's "country club" comment was a cheap shot that is without basis in fact. It sounds as if Mandel might be grinding an axe regarding his lack of access to the team during the Carr-era. Coach Carr ran a tough program during his 13-year tenure as Head Coach of the Wolverines. Furthermore, contrary to Mandel's assertion, the program achieved great success in the decade (1998-2007) following the Wolverines National Championship of 1997.
In the 10 seasons following 1997, the Wolverines won the Big Ten title four (4) times and had a won/lost record of 94-32 (.746%). Also, Michigan won three consecutive New Year's Day bowl games during that era ('99 Citrus Bowl; '00 Orange Bowl; '01 Citrus Bowl). In fact, Michigan played in a bowl game every season during the past decade including three (3) Rose Bowl games. Michigan's five bowl victories in the past ten seasons equal the number of bowl victories achieved by Coach Schembechler during his 21-year head coaching career at Michigan.
Coach Rodriguez definitely is running a different style of program than did Coach Carr. Coach Rodriguez' style is also much more media-friendly. That does not mean, however, that Coach Carr ran a country club. As illustrated above, Coach Carr achieved great success in the decade following the National Championship season of 1997. I hope that the Wolverines can experience similar success under Coach Rodriguez. Go Blue!
*Note: Photo of Coach Carr from the 11/3/07 game vs. MSU by DAVID GURALNICK/The Detroit News

4 Comments:

At 4:28 PM, Blogger TanqTenNU11 said...

Except for the fact that Michigan is 1-5 against Ohio State and the team hasn't been to a National Championship GAME where OSU has been to 3.

 
At 4:52 PM, Blogger mzgoblue said...

Don't forget that Coach Carr started out 5-1 against OSU in his first 6 games. Also, he WON as many National Championships (one) as OSU has since the 1990s although the Buckeyes have been in the title game three times in the past decade.

 
At 3:34 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cheap shot or not, Mandel and others in the mainsteam media are not off-base in asking questions like these.
Carr is a good man and a very good, personal coach to the players. But as far as the UM program is concerned, I have always questioned his judgement of hiring, rewarding and tolerating the most incompetent assistant coaches in UM football history: Brady Hoke, Mike DeBord, Jim Herrmann and Andy Moeller, Mike Gittleson. This is what happens when "but he's a michigan man!"chronism takes over a program rather then hiring the best personnel to do the job. This is probably the number one reason why Michigan teams have underachieved under Carr. Carr and DeBord believed scoring touchdowns was optional and that games must be won by defense alone. Check out where Michigan's offense has been ranked the last 13 years nationally. It's an embarrassment to say the least. Conservative play calling and the nation's most predictable playbook ruled the day.

Now, no more. Finally, Big Ten opponents will have to account for both Michigan's superior talent AS WELL AS superior coaching. It's about time.

Carr was good. But RR and staff is just 100 fold better.

 
At 10:55 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The country club is single handedly responsiable for the losses last year to ASU and OR. Those boys were visiably out of shape and unprepaired to start the season. Sounds like a country club to me.

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home